Worst of the Week - Five Things That Were Good About Countdown:
1. The Flash: "Sorrywaytoobsuysavinglivesgetotsafetygottago!" It's sad that, out of all the characterizations in all of Countdown, that was probably the only one that made any sense.
2. Ray Palmer remembered he wasn't entirely useless!
3. Someone, namely Superman, reminded Kyle that he's not the BESTEST superhero ever, and should, essentially shut up already. Considering Kyle's hypocritical holier-than-thou attitude through Countdown, it was a welcome change.
4. No one mentioned the stupid "turns people to rats" virus.
5. No Jason appearances, which meant no hypocritical morality lessons from Kyle, Donna, or Mary Marvel.
Five Things That Were Awful About Countdown:
1. So, since when does Superman shrug and say, eh, they can't be saved, never mind trying?
2. The Justice League was particularly useless here, with the exception of Ray Palmer, who was only marginally useless, compared to his previous Countdown characterization.
3. No Jason.
4. No Piper.
5. The "death of Darkseid" and the father-son battle had all the emotional impact of a paper cut.
Overall Score: 1 yay out of 5.
Doormat Score: 0 doormats out of 5.
Best of the Week - Six Things That Were Fantastic About Captain America 37
1. The entirely human reactions between the characters. Unlike other "big events," like Countdown and Civil War, Brubaker continues to make his Bucky-as-Cap arc about perfectly human reactions to both Steve's death and the world that Steve's death has brought.
2. Clint's reaction to Bucky and Bucky's reaction to that. I was kind of afraid for a second that the boys would decide to be really stupid and their argument would degenerate into the standard "who would win in a fight" contest. Brubaker proved me wrong, and proved that yeah, it only takes one person to have some sense in a battle for it not to happen.
3. I have been waiting for Falcon to respond to Bucky, and more importantly, Tony going behind his back and appointing Bucky as the new Cap. That Brubaker was able to show Sam as greatly upset and disappointed because he's worried about Bucky is a stroke of great characterization on Bucky's behalf.
4. "look out for the internet" - Oh, Brubaker. That's not supposed to be funny, is it? Because I LOLed. Also, Bucky's whole dream/nightmare as a whole was fantastically well done. It made me both miss Steve and hurt for Bucky.
5. Completely shallow, but yay for chest hair. Men in comics never have chest hair, and darn it, they should.
6. Sharon seems more in control of herself than in previous issues. I approve, muchly.
Overall Score: 5 yays out of 5
Doormat Score: 0 doormats out of 5
Quick Thoughts:
Flash 239
For the second month in a row, I am looking forward to the next month's Flash...what is that about? It's new, confusing, and absolutely delightful. Red Arrow shows more "Titans are Family" philosophy in the few panels he is in than in the entirety of Judd's disgraceful Titans issue, Jai and Iris are far better candidates for the current Teen Titans than the current crop.
Can we skip ahead a few years, and have the Lian-Iris-Jai-Milagro Teen Titans? Possibly mentored by Jaime? Because I would read that and possibly enjoy it more than I am current Teen Titans.
Yeah, yeah, never gonna happen. A girl can dream, though. *G*
I digressed from the point, which was that I truly enjoyed this peek of Wally and his family trying to balance superhero life with the demands of actually being a family. The only negative I have is that the Justice League's reactions were kind of off .
Overall Score: 4 yays out of 5.
Doormat Score: 0 doormats out of 5.
Catwoman 78
"My god, girl. I hope nothing happened. I know you're a match for anyone, for anything. But a kid...A kid changes everything."
Oh, and here I thought it was Pfeifer's fault that Catwoman has sucked for so long - I never would have thought to blame Helena!
This book is getting canceled soon, and honestly, as sad as I should be about the lack of Selina Kyle book to buy...I can't. I mean, if your dog has rabies when you shoot it, you have to feel like you're doing her a favor, don't you? I don't want a Catwoman book where Slam is smarter and more interesting than the lead character, I don't want a Catwoman book where Selina gives up because it's easier than continuing to fight, and I don't want a book in which Catwoman is anything but the conniving, scheming, intelligent woman she's supposed to be.
This book lost sight of all of those things when Pfeifer took over, and I for one am glad for the ax its receiving, if only because it will make the pain finally stop.
As for this issue in particular, the art inside was gorgeous, the art on the cover not as much. Yes, let's have our female characters bite each other in fights. That's not pandering to a horrible stereotype at all, is it?
Overall Score: 0 yays out of 5.
Doormat Score: 5 doormats out of 5 for the goddamn cover alone.
Superman 675
You know how once in a while, you go to the soda machine on a nice hot day, put in your change, open your soda, and take a nice long drink, only to discover it's flat? That's what this issue was. Everyone said and did the right things, but the overall emotional punch that should have been there (the underlining theme was Clark's heart, for god's sake) was missing.
At the end of the issue, I didn't hate it, but I didn't like it either. Mostly, I just didn't care, and that complete lack of caring is not how I should feel about one of the three main DC properties' book particularly when Superman is my favorite character.
Overall Score: 2 yays out of 5.
Doormat Score: Well, Lois remembered that she is a reporter for 1 whole panel! However, since this isn't the Silver Age, that's really not enough for me. So, 3.5 doormats out of 5.
Additional Sentiments...